Active ETFs: Beyond the hype
The US$1 trillion plus exchange-traded fund (ETF) industry* has been one of the fastest-growing segments of the asset management business, fundamentally changing the way institutional and individual investors alike access new asset classes and build diversified portfolios, writes Jonathan Steinberg, CEO of WisdomTree in his August 1 entry to the The WisdomTree Blog.
Yet today, the vast majority of the industry’s assets are in passive ETFs – funds that seek to track an underlying index. Will actively managed ETFs power the next leg of industry growth, or will active management remain the domain of such traditional investment structures as mutual funds and hedge funds? While most media stories depict a slow start and uncertain future, I see just the opposite. How can I be so sure?
It partly comes down to definitions. In ETF Land, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has determined an ETF is considered passive if it tracks an index. So, the logic follows, an ETF that does not track an underlying index must be active. Consider WisdomTree’s Currency ETFs—these funds seek to deliver the movement of foreign currency and its income rates available to US investors.
While this may not be what the media and industry pundits were envisioning when they talked about active ETFs, the fact of the matter is there’s no index for the spot price of the Chinese yuan or the Brazilian real, and these actively managed ETFs have found a home in many investors’ portfolios. Bending the names and classifications further, consider the wave of alternative strategy indexes that seek to outperform traditional, market capitalization-weighted indexes such as the S&P 500.
Isn’t that what active managers have been striving to do for decades?
In my opinion, a performance-oriented strategy representing something other than capitalization-weighted market exposure is active in philosophy, if not SEC designation. By that measure, WisdomTree and several others aim to provide an active experience for investors in our rules-based equity ETFs. Consider the case of PIMCO, the world’s largest bond investor. On March 1, 2012, they launched an ETF version of their well-known Total Return Fund run by well-known bond investor Bill Gross. The move was widely cited as a litmus test for the feasibility and investor appetite for traditional active management in the ETF wrapper. Only four months later, this active ETF has gathered roughly $1.8 billion in assets under management.
Whether utilising the active ETF designation to achieve unique exposures outside the world of indexing, using smart indexes to try to do something fundamentally active such as striving to beat the market, or doing good old-fashioned stock and bond picking in the investor-friendly ETF wrapper, active ETFs are here already, and we believe they’re not going away.
*Source: Investment Company Institute, June 2012